Previous Entry | Next Entry

The Iron Giant: Unhappy-Ending Version

robot-heart
Okay, if you're like me, you loved The Iron Giant. It's one of the best science-fiction movies ever, a touching story of friendship and meaningful social commentary (both past and present, as discussed in this Wired article). It works great for both the YA crowd and adults. It garnered both Hugo and Nebula Award recognition. I loved the simple, hand-drawn animation. And even though we all cry when the iron giant gets blown to smithereens heroically saving the town, we cheer when we learn during the final sequence that he's piecing himself back together again.

Hooray! Happy ending!

Except... did you know that the writers and director left out a crucial scene in the theatrical version? One that provides the iron giant's back-story, a scene they wished they had been able to finish? Here it is in sketch and voice-over form:
HOLY CRAP.

You know what that means? Right: The iron giant is part of a Berserker-like army of planet-killing monsters, and our Lovable Iron Hero™ participated in xenocide and planetary destruction on at least one occasion prior to visiting Earth. Only a knock on the head saved all life on this planet from his murderous programming.



So, when he reassembles, will he be whole again? Following original programming? And thus destroying all life on Earth - maybe Earth itself? And what of the rest of the robot army? Are they on their way here, too, or maybe nearby, searching for their missing life-annihilating soldier? HOLY FINAL-MASS-EXTINCTION, BATMAN!

Note that the movie dudes talk about this unifinished scene not as a bad idea or something they decided to cut because it WOULD CAUSE ETERNAL NIGHTMARES for the kids in the audience, but as an important part of the iron giant's back-story. So THIS HAPPENED, people. The iron giant murdered BILLIONS of life-forms - nay, TRILLIONS. And that's if he only destroyed one planet.

And where is this army of life-hating Berserkers now? I'm assuming they didn't arrive in the 1950s of the movie's time, because our tech then would have ensured Earth's annihilation. Are they en route now? Could we hope to repel them using today's tech? Could the nations of Earth unite in time to defend our planet against such machines? I mean, nuclear weapons cannot destroy these monsters! They just disperse the parts until they can reassemble. Even if we could stop one, could we hope to stop AN ARMY OF INDESTRUCTIBLE MACHINES THAT ARE ESSENTIALLY SENTIENT, PLANET-KILLING GUNS? And even if our Iron Giant Hero™ were to retain his flawed programming and try to defend us, could he possibly hope to stand against an army of similar beings?

Doubtful, even if his name was John Rambo.

So I think we know why they never made a sequel. It wasn't because the movie flopped at the box office; something called The Iron Giant 2: The End of All Life on Earth doesn't have quite the child-friendly tone that the audience might expect.

I'll watch this movie in a different light next time, that's for sure.

Chris

Comments

( 7 comments — Leave a comment )
frugurl27
May. 1st, 2012 08:00 pm (UTC)
Well. Thanks for ruining my childhood.
mckitterick
May. 1st, 2012 08:56 pm (UTC)
Only in retrospect. And of course it wasn't me who ruined it; it's the writers and director are responsible for all this ruination.
dotar_sojat
May. 2nd, 2012 03:00 am (UTC)
You know, I wondered if there was ever going to be a sequel where another Iron Giant comes to the earth to take care of business.

On the subject of if the Iron Giant, once re-assembled, would follow its original programing, I don't think you have to worry. The movie implies that it has (or gains) the power to choose whether to follow its programming or not.

But perhaps we are too gloomy? Perhaps the sequel could be that the Iron Giant returns to space, to emancipate his fellow robots from their role as murderous weapons. That would be awesome!

mckitterick
May. 2nd, 2012 03:06 am (UTC)
Ooh, I like that version!

The Iron Prophet

stuology
May. 2nd, 2012 03:12 am (UTC)
I love that movie. For some reason, I already knew that. Or assumed that. Was this something as an extra on the DVD?
mckitterick
May. 2nd, 2012 03:15 am (UTC)
Might have been an extra that wasn't on my (old) DVD. Or I might have blocked it.
stuology
May. 2nd, 2012 03:19 am (UTC)
I bet I've seen it, which is how it got implanted in my head. Now I want to watch the movie again.
( 7 comments — Leave a comment )