Chris McKitterick (mckitterick) wrote,
Chris McKitterick
mckitterick

My take on the Prop 8 decision.

I've been looking over the California Supreme Court's ruling on Proposition 8 (took me a while - it's over 125 pages long), approved by the majority of Cali voters last year, which added Section 7.5 to Article I of the California Constitution.

Okay, like many people, when I first heard about the decision, I was pissed off and started re-thinking the notion of California being a progressive state. But looking into the results a bit more got me thinking. Notes:
  1. At the time of the ruling, there were 18,000 same-sex marriages in California.

  2. This new article of the Cali constitution states that “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.”

  3. The ruling also suggests that same-sex couples should be afforded all the same legal rights that male-female couples get to enjoy... but they can't call it "marriage."

  4. The ruling goes to great lengths to point out that Californians can change their constitution about as easily as most people change socks, noting how much more difficult it is to do so than it is to change the US Constitution.

  5. The ruling states that people in existing same-sex marriages that were legally performed (before Prop 8 was in force) get to stay married.

  6. That means 18,000 same-sex marriages in California are legal.

  7. Therefore, 6 invalidates 2.

  8. Therefore, this ruling says that - even though Prop 8 was legally pushed forward and Section 7.5 of article I of the California Constitution is legal and binding, it is meaningless and contradictory.
So my overall reading of the ruling is this: The California Supremes are giving the Prop-Eighters exactly what they asked for... whether it’s what they wanted or not.

And that's a good thing for human rights.

Now if only they could get as up-to-date as Iowa ;-)

Chris
Tags: the human condition
Subscribe

  • Writing, blogging, life - also JETBIKE!

    I've been mostly neglecting LJ of late. Are you on Tumblr? I am! In fact, these days I mostly post there, which I often auto-cross-post to my…

  • Apologetic Updataliciousness

    Oh my gosh, I had no idea that I hadn't posted here for, what... three weeks now? MANY APOLOGIES! My absence is largely due to ten million little…

  • Blizzard Means Writing.

    KU officials closed campus last night, fearing Snowpocalypse. Waking up today to see only a light dusting provoked taunting words from me, but then…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments