Chris McKitterick (mckitterick) wrote,
Chris McKitterick

oooh, SF vs. fantasy debate

In Kij's journal, someone said that fantasy "can be much more exciting and forward looking and world-rocking than SF, because it isn't bounded in the same way." I had to argue, of course. Lemme know what you think:

SF isn't bounded by anything except the requirements of internal logic, as is good fantasy. And I think SF has the potential to have a greater effect on the world because much of it is realistic -- that is, we can extrapolate from the now into the vision of the SF story and see how we might be affected by change or how we must act to enact or avoid that change. Most of fantasy is about the individual or clan, whereas most of SF is about the human species; though perhaps told from the pov of an individual, what happens in an SF story is seldom limited to that one individual.

Future stories, for example, by definition are about change and the human species' survival into that future. Stories where people can travel from star to star are similarly powerful. Historical stories tell little about what is to come, though they can be about the moments when things changed (and that makes 'em appeal to SF readers). That's why alternate history is so popular among SF readers, or stories about inventors -- sure, I write mostly SF, but my next story (Plug: coming out next month in the Synergy SF anthology) is an alternate history about Cyrano. What makes it SF (though it's a story about faith) is that it's the moment when the world changed... though it's not our past.

Tags: science fiction

  • Radical kindness

    My response to the original poster's call for "radical kindness": " ultimately i think kindness is the most radical thing you can do…

  • Calling all Trump voters:

    I acknowledge that you can't ALL support the awful things your chosen candidate said during the campaign. You might even believe that he just…

  • We live on the cusp of the greatest Golden Age

    Just watched the PBS Hamilton musical documentary, and it made me cry all over again to witness the genius that went into making this brilliant…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.